Culture

A Humpback Off Pier 45, a Young Whale Feeds Its Way Up the Hudson

The third Hudson humpback in ten years by our count, as NOAA's tally puts New York and New Jersey at 88 of 274 coastal deaths since 2016

A Humpback Off Pier 45, a Young Whale Feeds Its Way Up the Hudson
Photo by Mike Doherty on UnsplashSuite646

Pier 45 runs out into the Hudson at the foot of Christopher Street. On Thursday the water off its end held something that rarely comes this far upriver, a young humpback whale, and by every account it was there for the fish.

A juvenile humpback whale swam into New York Harbor on Wednesday, November 11, 2026, and up the Hudson River on Thursday, November 12, from Lower Manhattan to Pier 45 in the West Village. Gotham Whale, the Staten Island research nonprofit tracking it, says it is chasing menhaden and has asked boats to slow down.

The first report placed the whale near the St. George ferry terminal on Staten Island on Wednesday. Gotham Whale's video from that day shows it spouting as a large container ship and a tug pass very close, FOX Weather reported on Friday. The group says the animal in the Hudson on Thursday is very likely the same one, and that it was lunge-feeding in the harbor as the cargo ship went by.

Why Is a Humpback in the Hudson?

Food, most likely. Gotham Whale told FOX Weather that the whales off New York are almost always in the Lower Bay, south of the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge, but that juveniles often push into the Upper Bay and the inner waterways after prey. The prey this time of year is Atlantic menhaden, a small oily fish also called bunker, which runs south along the Long Island and Jersey Shore beaches every fall. Some of the fish swing into the harbor on the way, and the whales follow.

That pattern is not new. When a humpback turned up near Pier 84 in December 2020, experts told ABC7 that the whales were migrating south but had paused here for the food, and the city's Parks Department credited cleaner water and plentiful menhaden for the rise in sightings.

What has changed is the number of whales doing it. Gotham Whale's NYC Humpback Whale Catalog, which identifies individuals by the markings on the underside of their tail flukes, holds data on more than 500 humpbacks seen in and around the city since 2012, and the group logged its 500th whale in late July, according to FOX Weather. Identifying the Hudson whale will take a clear photo of the underside of its flukes or its dorsal fin.

How Often Does This Happen?

Rarely, and almost always in late fall. By our count of the reports we could confirm, this is the third time in ten years that a humpback has made it into the Hudson along Manhattan. Here is Suite 646's timeline, with the gaps between visits counted in days.

November 2016. A whale was reported in New York Harbor on Thursday, November 17, and was breaching off West 96th Street on Sunday, November 20, ABC7 reported at the time. A later ABC7 report said that whale stayed in the river for about a week.

December 2020. A humpback was first seen near Pier 84 at about 4:15 p.m. on Monday, December 7, and again on Tuesday, December 8, closer to the Statue of Liberty. Gotham Whale identified it as NYC0089, a whale already in its catalog, Time Out New York reported. That visit came 1,478 days after the 2016 whale was seen off 96th Street.

November 2026. Near St. George on Wednesday, November 11, then in the Hudson from Lower Manhattan to Pier 45 on Thursday, November 12. That is 2,166 days after the first 2020 sighting, almost six years.

All three came between November 11 and December 8 on the calendar, during the fall menhaden run. Some reports this week have cited other Upper Bay or East River sightings in 2022 and 2024. We could not confirm those from a primary source, so they are not in our count.

All three came between November 11 and December 8 on the calendar.

Is the Whale Endangered?

Not under the Endangered Species Act, though it is still protected. North Atlantic humpbacks travel to the West Indies and Cape Verde to calve, NOAA Fisheries says. In September 2016 the National Marine Fisheries Service split the species into 14 distinct population segments, listed four as endangered and one as threatened, and found that the other nine, the West Indies segment among them, did not warrant listing. The final rule in the Federal Register took effect on October 11, 2016, which happens to be 37 days before the 2016 whale was first reported in the harbor.

The Marine Mammal Protection Act still covers every humpback, everywhere, according to NOAA Fisheries. Adults reach about 60 feet and 40 tons, the agency says, so even a juvenile is a large object in a shipping channel.

What Does NOAA's Death Count Show for New York?

That New York waters carry a big share of the losses. Since January 2016, NOAA has tracked elevated humpback deaths from Maine to Florida as an Unusual Mortality Event, a federal designation that opens an investigation into the cause. Its table, last updated November 5, 2026, counts 274 dead humpbacks along the coast.

New York accounts for 50 of them, 38 found in state waters and 12 offshore. Only Massachusetts, with 59, has more. Add New Jersey's 38 and the two states that share the harbor hold 88 of the 274, or 32 percent, by our arithmetic from NOAA's state-by-year table.

Here are New York and New Jersey together, year by year, from the same table.

2016, 7. 2017, 8. 2018, 10. 2019, 10. 2020, 13. 2021, 1. 2022, 6. 2023, 19. 2024, 6. 2025, 6. 2026 so far, 2.

The worst year was 2023, when the two states recorded 19 of the 37 deaths on the whole coast. NOAA says partial or full necropsies were done on about half the whales, and that of the 129 examined as of July 2025, about 45 percent showed evidence of human interaction, either a vessel strike or entanglement in fishing gear.

New York and New Jersey hold 88 of the 274 deaths NOAA has counted since 2016.

How Close Can Boats Get?

Gotham Whale is asking boaters to slow down, watch for spouts and stay at least 100 feet from the whale, and it put the message in capitals, saying vessel operators "MUST maintain caution and reduce speeds." NOAA's own national guidance asks for more room. The agency recommends watching large whales from at least 100 yards, "about the length of a football field," and says to slow to no-wake speed near marine mammals and to spend no more than 30 minutes watching any one animal, according to its marine life viewing guidelines.

The two figures differ by a factor of three, and the federal one is the safer bet. Young humpbacks chasing fish tend to ignore boat traffic, Gotham Whale says, which is exactly what its own video from Wednesday shows.

For people on land, the job is simpler. Gotham Whale is tracking this whale partly through photos the public sends in, and a clear shot of the flukes is the one its researchers can match to the catalog.

What Happens Next?

The whale leaves when the fish do. Gotham Whale told FOX Weather it expected the animal might linger into Friday, November 13. The 2016 whale stayed about a week, and the 2020 whale was seen on two days. Gotham Whale says it has recently identified dozens of humpbacks feeding close to shore along New York and New Jersey beaches. A whale that follows the menhaden back out past the Verrazzano would simply rejoin them.

The city has two other big arrivals on its November calendar. The 76-foot spruce that came down from Otsego County is already standing at Rockefeller Center, and the inflatables for the 100th Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade step off from the Upper West Side on November 26. Neither one picked its own route.

The next number to watch is the one in the catalog. If the flukes match a whale Gotham Whale already knows, the Hudson visitor gets a name like NYC0089. If not, it becomes a new entry in a catalog that passed 500 this summer.

ReadNext

TheLate
Edition

New stories every Friday night, in your inbox. Nothing else.