Five for Broadway, Every 2027 Grammy Cast Album Nominee Is a Broadway Cast
Chess, The Lost Boys, Ragtime, Schmigadoon! and Two Strangers fill the category, and only two of the five will still be running on Grammy night
All five nominees for Best Musical Theater Album at the 2027 Grammy Awards are Broadway cast recordings. The Recording Academy named them on Monday, November 16, 2026: Chess, The Lost Boys, Ragtime, Schmigadoon! and Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York).
The list went out live from New York City at 7:45 a.m., according to ABC News, with the full slate posted on Grammy.com at nine. The ceremony itself is in Los Angeles, at Crypto.com Arena on Sunday, February 7, 2027. That is 83 days after the announcement.
The cast album category belongs to the blocks around Times Square. What surprised us was a different number. Two of the five shows have already left Broadway, and a third plays its last performance on November 29.
Who Is Nominated for Best Musical Theater Album?
The Recording Academy's category page credits each album to its principal vocalists, its producers and its writers. Here is the field as the Academy lists it.
Chess (2025 Broadway Cast). Vocalists Nicholas Christopher, Hannah Cruz, Bradley Dean, Lea Michele, Bryce Pinkham and Aaron Tveit. Produced by Benny Andersson, Ludvig Andersson and Brian Usifer. Music by Andersson and Björn Ulvaeus, lyrics by Tim Rice.
The Lost Boys (Original Broadway Cast). Vocalists Shoshana Bean, LJ Benet, Ali Louis Bourzgui, Paul Alexander Nolan, Benjamin Pajak and Maria Wirries. Produced by Kyler England, Adrianne Gonzalez, Gabriel Mann and Ethan Popp, with England, Gonzalez and Mann also credited as the writers.
Ragtime (2025 Broadway Cast). Vocalists Colin Donnell, Joshua Henry, Caissie Levy, Nichelle Lewis, Ben Levi Ross and Brandon Uranowitz. Produced by Lynn Ahrens, Sean Patrick Flahaven and Stephen Flaherty. Music by Flaherty, lyrics by Ahrens.
Schmigadoon! (Original Broadway Company). Vocalists Alex Brightman, Sara Chase and Ana Gasteyer. Produced by Doug Besterman, David Chase, Cinco Paul and Scott M. Riesett. Words and music by Paul.
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) (Original Broadway Cast). Vocalists Christiani Pitts and Sam Tutty. Produced by Jim Barne, Nick Finlow, Tim Jackson and Lux Pyramid. Music by Barne, lyrics by Kit Buchan.
That is 19 credited singers across five albums, by our count. Two Strangers needs only two of them, because the show has only two people in it. Ragtime and Chess credit six apiece.
Two of the five shows have already left Broadway, and a third plays its last performance on November 29.
Which of the Nominated Shows Are Still Running?
Three, for now. We checked each nominee against the Broadway League's weekly grosses for the week ending November 8, 2026, the latest week the League had posted when we looked on November 17. Here is where each one stands.
The Lost Boys, Palace Theatre. Opened April 26, 2026. Still running, and the strongest of the three, with a gross of $1,282,676 and 94 percent of seats filled that week. Bean won a Tony for it in June, which we covered when the show became the longest-running vampire musical on Broadway.
Schmigadoon!, Nederlander Theatre. Opened April 20, 2026. Still running, with $861,060 and 86 percent capacity. Its cast album was released on August 21, 2026, only days before the eligibility window closed.
Two Strangers, Longacre Theatre. Opened November 20, 2025. Running until Sunday, November 29, 2026, its announced final performance. It took in $581,025 at 71 percent capacity, the lowest capacity figure of all 35 shows on the League's list that week. The nomination lands 13 days before the closing.
Ragtime, Vivian Beaumont Theater. Opened October 16, 2025, at Lincoln Center Theater, which says on its show page that the revival won four Tony Awards, including best revival of a musical. It no longer appears on the League's list. The Beaumont now holds A Few Good Men.
Chess, Imperial Theatre. Opened November 16, 2025, exactly one year before the nominations. It closed on June 21, 2026, after 241 performances. The Imperial now houses 860.
Counting the days, Chess will have been closed for 231 days by Grammy night. Two Strangers will have been dark for 70.
Is This Unusual for the Category?
Not lately. We pulled the last three years of nominees from the Recording Academy's own pages. The 2025 field had six albums, Hell's Kitchen (the winner), Merrily We Roll Along, The Notebook, The Outsiders, Suffs and The Wiz. The 2026 field had five, Buena Vista Social Club (the winner), Death Becomes Her, Gypsy, Just in Time and Maybe Happy Ending. Every one of those 11 albums was credited to a Broadway cast.
Add this year's five and the category has gone 16 for 16 on Broadway since the 2025 ceremony.
Then we checked all 16 against the same League week. Seven are still playing on Broadway. The Outsiders at the Jacobs, Buena Vista Social Club at the Schoenfeld, Just in Time at Circle in the Square and Maybe Happy Ending at the Belasco join this year's three. The other nine are gone.
That number keeps shrinking. Two Strangers closes November 29. Buena Vista Social Club, last year's winner, closes January 17, 2027, as we reported when Broadway's January closing notices started to pile up. If nothing else posts a notice, five of the 16 will still be running on February 7.
How We Counted
We used the Recording Academy's category pages for the 2025, 2026 and 2027 Grammy Awards for the nominee lists and credits. Running status and box office come from the Broadway League's grosses page for the week ending November 8, 2026. A show counts as running if it appears on that list. Opening and closing dates and album release dates come from the productions' run records as compiled in their Wikipedia entries, checked against the League list, and Ragtime's Tony count comes from Lincoln Center Theater. Day counts are calendar days. We did not count cast albums of touring or Off-Broadway productions, because none were nominated in these three years.
What Happens Before February 7?
Final-round voting runs from December 10, 2026, to January 7, 2027, according to Variety. The ceremony airs on ABC and streams on Hulu, per the same report.
For voters, the race is between three revivals of a sort and two originals. Chess and Ragtime are new recordings of scores first heard on Broadway decades ago. The Lost Boys, Schmigadoon! and Two Strangers are original cast albums. Last year's winner and the year before were both originals.
For New Yorkers, the practical question is simpler. Two of these scores can only be heard on the album now. A third has 13 days left at the Longacre on West 48th Street. The Lost Boys and Schmigadoon! are still eight shows a week, and the League's figures say the vampires are the harder ticket.
The category is called musical theater. This year it could just as easily be called Broadway, and by February a few of its nominees will be memories of it.


