Sunday, Then Monday, Downstate and The Fantasticks Open on Broadway
Our tally of the reviews for two openings a block apart, Bruce Norris's play now extended to February 14 and a 66-year-old musical
Bruce Norris's Downstate opened at the Booth Theatre on Sunday, November 15, 2026, and The Fantasticks opened at the Hayes Theater on Monday, November 16. By our tally of the reviews, critics liked both, and they liked the play more.
The Booth is on West 45th Street and the Hayes is on West 44th, close enough that a critic could file on Sunday night and walk to the next opening on Monday. The two shows have almost nothing else in common. One is a play set in a group home in downstate Illinois. The other is the musical that ran for 42 years on Sullivan Street and never played Broadway until this fall.
How Were the Reviews for Downstate?
Strong. BroadwayWorld's Downstate review roundup collected 13 notices and gave the production an average of 86.2 percent. We read the excerpts from 12 of those outlets, leaving out one we do not cite, and 11 of them are clearly favorable. The twelfth, from Jonathan Mandell at New York Theater, is a reflection on the characters that does not declare a verdict in the lines quoted, so we left it unscored.
The praise runs hot. Brian Scott Lipton at Cititour calls it "the finest (and finest acted) show on Broadway." Johnny Oleksinski at the New York Post calls it "a veritable gasp-a-thon." Roma Torre at New York Stage Review warns it is not easy to watch and calls it "a stunning achievement." Robert Hofler at TheWrap labels his notice a rave and then adds that there are caveats.
Joe Mantello directs. The company is K. Todd Freeman, Francis Guinan, Thomas Sadoski, Al'Jaleel McGhee, Cassie Beck, Adrian Martinez, Ivy Wolk and Liza Colón-Zayas. TheaterMania's Zachary Stewart calls one of the central turns "a heroic performance."
The reviews arrived with news. On Monday the production extended its run, which was due to end on January 10, 2027, through February 14. That adds 35 days to a 12-week limited engagement and gives the play 91 days from opening night to its new final performance.
When we wrote about the Booth run in October, previews were set for October 17. BroadwayWorld has since reported that the first preview was postponed more than once, the second time because of illness in the company.
By our tally of the reviews, critics liked both, and they liked the play more.
How Were the Reviews for The Fantasticks?
Warm, with more reservations. BroadwayWorld's Fantasticks roundup gathered 17 notices and averaged them at 77.6 percent. Of the 16 we read, 11 are favorable by our reading, four are mixed and one is negative.
The favorable ones lean on the word charm. Greg Evans at Deadline praises the production's devotion to "a work that all but defined Off Broadway charm." The Guardian's Richard Lawson calls it a warm invitation to "succumb to its gentle charms." Patrick Ryan at USA Today calls Christopher Gattelli's revival "sublime and heart-tugging."
The mixed notices worry about scale. Charles Isherwood at The Wall Street Journal sees "a meticulously mounted replica, on a modestly larger scale." Mandell, at New York Theater, writes that the enlargement "feels far more intrusive than the change to two boys." TheaterMania's David Gordon and Cititour's Lipton are the other two in the middle. The negative review is from David Finkle at New York Stage Review, who found the central romance "tepid." His colleague at the same outlet, Melissa Rose Bernardo, liked it.
The change Mandell mentions is the big one. In this version, as we reported when previews began, the two fathers are mothers and the young lovers are two young men. Critics mostly took it in stride. New York Theatre Guide's Joe Dziemianowicz calls the gay sons "a total non-issue."
Gattelli directs and choreographs, and he is having a big week. The Broadway Schmigadoon!, which he also staged, picked up a Grammy nomination for its cast album on the same morning.
What Were the Box Office Numbers Before Opening?
Both houses were nearly full in previews. In the Broadway League's figures for the week ending November 8, Downstate grossed $348,713 at the Booth with 98 percent of seats sold. The Fantasticks grossed $416,458 at the Hayes at 97 percent. Of the 35 shows on the League's list that week, only five sold a larger share of their seats than Downstate, all at 99 or 100 percent.
Those are small-house numbers. Hamilton grossed $2.7 million the same week. Neither of these shows is built for that. They are built to fill a few hundred seats a night and get people talking.
When Can You See Them?
Downstate plays the Booth, 222 West 45th Street, through Sunday, February 14, 2027. The Fantasticks plays the Hayes, 240 West 44th Street. Second Stage Theater's calendar for the show runs through Sunday, February 7, 2027, 108 days after its first preview on October 22. The Hayes production runs 2 hours and 5 minutes with a 15-minute intermission, according to Second Stage.
How We Counted
We used the two BroadwayWorld roundups as published on November 15 and 16 and read each excerpt ourselves. Favorable means the quoted lines recommend the show. Mixed means they praise and fault it in roughly equal measure. We excluded one outlet's review from both counts by house policy. The percentages are BroadwayWorld's own and include every review it collected. Box office figures are the League's.
One Sunday, one Monday, two curtains a block apart. The play got the bigger cheers. The musical got the older friends.


