Culture

Three Curtains on January 3, Broadway's Long Runners Start Leaving

SIX, & Juliet and Stranger Things close the same Sunday and Buena Vista Social Club follows two weeks later, after 5,389 performances between them

Three Curtains on January 3, Broadway's Long Runners Start Leaving
Photo by Manos Gkikas on UnsplashSuite646

Three Broadway musicals have posted the same last day, Sunday, January 3, 2027. A fourth leaves two weeks later.

SIX, & Juliet and Stranger Things: The First Shadow all close on January 3, 2027, and Buena Vista Social Club closes on January 17, after producers announced the date on November 6. By Suite 646's tally of the producers' own figures, the four will have played 5,389 regular Broadway performances between them.

The announcements came in pieces over five months, Stranger Things in June, SIX in August, & Juliet in September and Buena Vista last week. Put side by side, they say a lot about how long a hit lasts on Broadway now.

How Long Did Each Show Run?

Here are the four, longest first, with the theater, the official opening night, the closing date, the days between the two and the performance count each production announced.

SIX, at the Lena Horne Theatre. Opened October 3, 2021. Closes January 3, 2027. 1,918 days. 2,178 regular performances and 47 previews.

& Juliet, at the Stephen Sondheim Theatre. Opened November 17, 2022. Closes January 3, 2027. 1,508 days. 1,723 regular performances and 20 previews.

Buena Vista Social Club, at the Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre. Opened March 19, 2025. Closes January 17, 2027. 669 days. 767 regular performances and 27 previews.

Stranger Things: The First Shadow, at the Marquis Theatre. Opened April 22, 2025. Closes January 3, 2027. 621 days. 721 regular performances and 19 previews.

SIX had the strangest start of the four. It began performances in February 2020, stopped on March 12, 2020, when the pandemic shut Broadway, and only officially opened on October 3, 2021, according to Broadway.com. Its count of more than five years at the Lena Horne starts from that opening, and the show has been planning its goodbye since its closing notice in August.

Neither will reach a second anniversary.

The two younger shows are the 2025 class. Buena Vista and Stranger Things opened five weeks apart that spring and both collected Tony Awards that June. Neither will reach a second anniversary.

Which Show Is Selling Best Right Now?

Buena Vista Social Club, by a wide margin, which makes its exit the most surprising of the four. In the Broadway League's grosses for the week ending November 8, it filled 94 percent of the Schoenfeld and took in $873,691 over eight performances. & Juliet filled 91 percent and grossed $851,179. Stranger Things filled 80 percent of the Marquis, the biggest of the four by weekly attendance, at an average ticket of $84.03, the lowest of the group. SIX filled 77 percent and grossed $704,152.

By our arithmetic the four shows grossed $3,168,782 that week, 8.6 percent of the $36,753,750 taken in by all 35 shows on Broadway. They sold 30,571 tickets.

Capacity is not the whole story of a closing. Running costs, theater deals and touring plans all count, and the announcements we read gave no reasons. They did point to life elsewhere. Buena Vista Social Club's North American tour runs through September 2027 and a West End production is set for 2027, Broadway.com reported. SIX's U.S. tour continues, and & Juliet was touring North America through November, according to a September report on its closing.

What Changes Before the Last Night?

Buena Vista keeps adding faces on the way out. Xolo Maridueña joins as Juan de Marcos on November 17, and Natalie Venetia Belcon rejoins the company on November 30, Broadway.com reported when the closing was announced. Gina Torres, who joined as Omara this fall, is still in the role, and the former Yankee Bernie Williams plays guitar in the band through November 29.

One listing disagrees on the address. TheaterMania's closing report puts the show at the Jacobs Theatre. The Broadway League's own weekly grosses list it at the Schoenfeld, and so did every other report we read, so that is the theater we use.

How We Counted

Performance counts and opening dates come from the closing announcements as each production gave them. Days are counted from the official opening night to the final performance. Weekly grosses and capacity come from the Broadway League's report for the week ending November 8, 2026, and the combined totals are our own sums. We found these four January closings in the reports we read. Other shows may still post January dates.

From Wednesday, November 11, the first three have 53 days left. Buena Vista has 67. The season's grosses, which already ran behind last year this fall, will have to carry on without four musicals that each filled most of their seats into November.

ReadNext

TheLate
Edition

New stories every Friday night, in your inbox. Nothing else.