Felix and Oscar Again, Carell and Reilly Bring Back The Odd Couple
The 15-week revival starts previews March 3 at the Stephen Sondheim Theatre, and our table of every Broadway Odd Couple since 1965 shows how short the sequels have run

The last time Felix Ungar and Oscar Madison shared a Broadway apartment, Nathan Lane and Matthew Broderick closed the lease on Sunday, June 4, 2006, at the Brooks Atkinson Theatre on West 47th Street. The poker table has been folded for 7,577 days by the time the next pair moves in.
Steve Carell will play Felix and John C. Reilly will play Oscar in a Broadway revival of Neil Simon's The Odd Couple, producers announced on Thursday, November 12, 2026. Thomas Kail, who directed Hamilton, stages the 15-week limited run at the Stephen Sondheim Theatre, 124 West 43rd Street, with previews from Wednesday, March 3, 2027, and opening night on Tuesday, March 23, Playbill reported.
It will be the fourth full Broadway production of the play in 62 years, and the first since the Lane and Broderick revival. We counted every one of them.
Who Else Is in the Cast?
The poker game is stacked. Laura Benanti, a Tony winner for Gypsy, plays Gwendolyn Pigeon, and Heléne Yorke, from the series The Other Two, plays her sister Cecily. James Monroe Iglehart, who won his Tony as the Genie in Aladdin, is Murray the cop. Kevin Del Aguila plays Roy, Rob McClure plays Vinnie and David Zayas plays Speed.
McClure knows the building. He was in Mrs. Doubtfire at the Sondheim in 2021 and 2022, according to Playbill's listing for that production.
David Korins designs the set, Brenda Abbandandolo the costumes, Stacey Derosier the lights and Jill BC Du Boff the sound. Jeffrey Seller, who produced Hamilton and Rent, produces with The Season (Mike Karns and Steven Tartick), Kail and Emanuel Azenberg.
Kail said in a statement quoted by Playbill that "Neil Simon wrote one of the great American comedies," and that "underneath the extraordinary humor is something deeply human."
Underneath the extraordinary humor is something deeply human.
How Long Did the Other Odd Couples Run?
Not as long as the first. Here is Suite 646's table of every Broadway staging of the play, built from Playbill's production records, with the days between opening and closing nights counted by us.
1965. Plymouth Theatre, West 45th Street, the house now named for Gerald Schoenfeld. Walter Matthau as Oscar and Art Carney as Felix, directed by Mike Nichols. Opened Wednesday, March 10, 1965. Closed July 2, 1967. 844 days. 966 performances in Playbill's count.
1985. Broadhurst Theatre, West 44th Street. Simon's female version, with Rita Moreno as Olive Madison and Sally Struthers as Florence Ungar, directed by Gene Saks. Opened June 11, 1985. Closed February 23, 1986. 257 days. 295 performances and 9 previews.
1991. Belasco Theatre, West 44th Street. One night only, June 23, 1991, as a benefit for the National Actors Theatre with Jack Klugman as Oscar and Tony Randall as Felix. 1 performance.
2005. Brooks Atkinson Theatre, West 47th Street. Nathan Lane as Oscar and Matthew Broderick as Felix, directed by Joe Mantello. Opened Thursday, October 27, 2005. Closed June 4, 2006. 220 days. 249 performances and 28 previews.
2027. Stephen Sondheim Theatre, West 43rd Street. John C. Reilly as Oscar and Steve Carell as Felix, directed by Thomas Kail. First preview Wednesday, March 3, 2027. Opening Tuesday, March 23. A 15-week limited engagement, with no closing date posted yet.
The arithmetic is plain. The original played more performances than the two full revivals that followed it put together, 966 against 544. Its 844 days on Broadway are more than three times the run of either sequel.
One figure needs a footnote. Playbill's vault lists 966 performances for the 1965 production, including two previews. Wikipedia's account of the play splits the same total into 964 regular performances and the two previews, and says the show moved to the Eugene O'Neill Theatre during the run. We use Playbill's total.
The 1965 company won big. Matthau took the Tony for best actor in a play, Simon won as author and Oliver Smith won for the scenery, according to Playbill's awards list for the production. The cast changed fast once the hit was secure. Jack Klugman replaced Matthau in November 1965, and Eddie Bracken took over from Carney that October, Wikipedia records.
What Have Carell and Reilly Done on Broadway Before?
Not much, which is part of the bet. By Playbill's records, Carell has one Broadway credit. He played the title role in Uncle Vanya, Heidi Schreck's adaptation of Chekhov, at the Vivian Beaumont Theater in 2024. That production opened April 24, 2024, and closed June 16 after 62 performances and 22 previews. It averaged 94.31 percent of capacity and grossed $10,219,195, according to Playbill's record of the Vanya run.
Reilly has three. He joined The Grapes of Wrath at the Cort Theatre in 1990 as a replacement, playing Noah. In 2000 he alternated the brothers Austin and Lee in True West at Circle in the Square, which earned him a Tony nomination for best actor in a play, his Playbill credits show. In 2005 he was Stanley Kowalski in A Streetcar Named Desire at Studio 54.
That puts Reilly's return almost 22 years after his last opening night, which was April 26, 2005. Carell's comes 990 days after Vanya closed.
Both men bring something the Lane and Broderick pairing also had, a long shared history with an audience. Playbill calls the 2005 revival a quasi-Producers reunion. Carell and Reilly arrive as screen actors known to most of the house from The Office and Stan and Ollie, rather than from the stage.
When Can You Get Tickets?
General sales open Tuesday, November 17, at 10 a.m. Eastern, through Criterion Ticketing, according to the production's official site. An American Express card member presale started on November 12 and runs until 9:59 a.m. that Tuesday. Counted from the first preview, 15 weeks would carry the run to the middle of June 2027.
The house is not empty yet. & Juliet plays the Sondheim until Sunday, January 3, 2027, one of three musicals closing that day. By our count from Playbill's November 12 bookings list, that leaves the theater dark for 58 nights before Felix starts scrubbing the kitchen. The Odd Couple is one of 18 productions now booked into Broadway houses for the winter and spring, a queue we laid out in our map of who gets the keys this season.
Kail has had a busy fall on 42nd Street too. The 24 Hour Plays honored him at its gala at the Todd Haimes Theatre on November 2.
Why This Play, Again?
The Odd Couple has never really left the city. After the 1968 film with Matthau and Jack Lemmon, it returned on television in 1970, 1982 and 2015, with an animated version in 1975, Playbill notes. Simon's own female rewrite gave it a second Broadway life in 1985.
What the record shows is a play that reliably fills a season and then folds its tent. The revivals were built around stars, and they lasted about as long as the stars could stay. A 15-week booking makes that explicit from day one.
The first count that matters is 110 days away. That is how long it is from Friday, November 13, to the first preview on March 3, when Oscar's apartment gets its first audience in almost 21 years.



