Art

What the Baums Paid, a $115,000 Rothko Sells for $17.7 Million at Sotheby's

Our arithmetic on Monday's Sotheby's evening sales, from a Joan Mitchell bought for $65,000 in 1986 to a night just under its low estimate

What the Baums Paid, a $115,000 Rothko Sells for $17.7 Million at Sotheby's
Photo by Or Hakim on UnsplashSuite646

A Mark Rothko that Theodore and Ruth Baum bought in 1983 for $115,000 sold at Sotheby's in New York on Monday night, November 16, 2026, for $17.7 million with fees. That is about 154 times what they paid, according to figures reported by The Art Newspaper.

It was one of 24 works from the Baum collection that opened Sotheby's November week at its Madison Avenue headquarters, the Breuer building at East 75th Street. All 24 sold. A second sale, The Now and Contemporary Evening Auction, followed the same night. Together the two brought $378.7 million with fees.

Sotheby's describes the Baums as collectors and philanthropists with homes in New York City, Southampton, Palm Beach and New Jersey. Its catalogue essay says the Rothko was their first purchase of contemporary art, and that they sold a collection of Impressionist and modern works on paper to afford it.

How Much Did the Baums' Paintings Gain?

A great deal, even after inflation. The Art Newspaper's report gives purchase prices for two of the lots. We ran them against the federal consumer price index.

The Rothko, Untitled. Bought in 1983 for $115,000. Sold for $17.7 million with fees. That is a gain of about 154 times, or 12.4 percent a year compounded over 43 years. In today's money, by the October 2026 consumer price index, the $115,000 is worth about $390,000. Measured that way, the painting returned roughly 45 times its real cost.

Joan Mitchell, Green Book of Barbara Guest. Bought in 1986 for $65,000. Sotheby's says the couple kept their Mitchell for four decades. Sold for $19.3 million with fees, the top Baum lot. That is about 297 times the price, or 15.3 percent a year over 40 years. The $65,000 is worth about $200,000 now, so the real multiple is roughly 96.

Two cautions belong next to those numbers. The sale prices include Sotheby's buyer's premium, which the Baums did not receive, and the purchase prices do not include whatever the couple paid in fees or insurance over four decades. The return to the estate is lower than the headline multiple. It is still a very good return.

In today's money, the $115,000 is worth about $390,000.

Did the Contemporary Sale Meet Its Estimate?

Just barely not. The Now and Contemporary Evening Auction hammered at $224.78 million, before fees, against a presale estimate of $226.2 million to $323.1 million, The Art Newspaper reported. By our arithmetic, that is $1.4 million, or 0.6 percent, under the low estimate. With fees it reached $268.7 million.

Of 53 lots, two were withdrawn and five failed to sell, including works by Ellsworth Kelly, Kerry James Marshall, Roy Lichtenstein and Keith Haring. That leaves 46 sold of the 51 that reached the block, a sell-through rate of 90 percent by our count.

The Baum sale did better against its numbers. Its estimate was $74.4 million to $109 million before fees, and it made $90.8 million, comfortably inside the range. About a third of its lots still hammered below their low estimates. Franz Kline's Figure, estimated at $4 million to $6 million, made $1.8 million hammer, 55 percent short of the low end.

What About the Lots We Previewed?

Last week we added up the estimates Sotheby's had published for its featured November lots. Two of those featured works from Monday's contemporary sale have reported results.

Yayoi Kusama's No. 3P.B., from 1960, was estimated at $10 million to $15 million. It hammered at $12.5 million, or $15 million with fees, an auction record for the artist, as The Art Newspaper reported. We wrote about Kusama's late work in Chelsea this fall.

Roy Lichtenstein's Reflections on "Painter and Model," from 1990, was estimated at $20 million to $30 million. It hammered at $22 million, $24.6 million with fees, and was the top lot of the contemporary sale. Both landed inside their ranges, in the lower half.

Sotheby's own lot pages show the sale as closed but keep the prices behind a login, so we used the reported figures for every result here.

How We Counted

Purchase prices, hammer prices, prices with fees, estimates and lot counts are from The Art Newspaper's report by Carlie Porterfield, published November 16. Acquisition years are checked against Sotheby's catalogue essay where it gives them. For inflation we used the annual average of the consumer price index for all urban consumers for the purchase year, 99.6 for 1983 and 109.6 for 1986, against 337.511 for October 2026. Annual rates are compound growth from the purchase year to 2026.

What Comes Next?

The week is not over. Sotheby's has more sales on Wednesday, November 18, and Christie's begins its evening sales at Rockefeller Center on Tuesday, November 17. Lucius Elliott, who runs Sotheby's contemporary marquee sales, told The Art Newspaper that "when your sale is the opener for a major season like this, there's always a sense of heightened anticipation."

The Baums waited 43 years on their Rothko. On Monday, the longest fight of the night, over a Jeff Koons called Bob-Tail, lasted six minutes, by The Art Newspaper's account.

ReadNext

TheLate
Edition

New stories every Friday night, in your inbox. Nothing else.